HomeCoursesMastering the Fundamentals of Management

The field of management in the EU

Chapter 2 · Organisations and management · lesson 2 of 74
Sample exercise available for free

Objectives

  • Understanding the field of management and its application to all organisations
  • Distinguishing the essential characteristics of organisations
  • Identify the different types of organisations and their management contexts
  • Analyse the role of stakeholders and the corporate social responsibility of the company
Good to know
This management unit covers all forms of organisations, whether for-profit or non-profit. Although we focus on companies, management principles apply broadly to public administrations, associations and non-profit bodies.

The scope of this teaching unit is that of organisations in general. While we will focus on a particular subset — for-profit organisations, in other words companies — the fundamental questions of management remain the same, regardless of whether the organisation is for-profit or non-profit.

Organisations and essential characteristics

The distinction between for-profit and non-profit is hardly relevant when analysing management issues within organisations. The constraints to take into account vary according to context, but the challenges remain largely similar. Leading a team within a public administration or a company may take different forms, but the human and organisational issues remain identical.

The proof lies in the circulation of tools and methods: non-profit organisations adopt strategic analysis and marketing tools designed in the private sector. Conversely, human resource management tools developed in companies now inspire management methods in the public sector. Certain organisational theories, notably sociological approaches, were moreover developed from analyses conducted in administrations and bureaucracies.

Definition
Organization
A specific human collective defined by boundaries, an objective and structured means. It is the object of study of management sciences.

According to Khandwalla, organisations are distinguished from other human groups (family, friends, community) by specific traits:

  • A specific purpose (an aim, a goal), unlike other communities such as the family
  • The presence of qualified personnel, a notion of no interest in unorganised human groups
  • Reliance on formalised communication systems
  • The production of rules, procedures and control arrangements specifying how individuals should behave and carry out their tasks
  • A secondary, if not nil, importance given to emotional bonds — an organization can function without strong emotional bonds, unlike a family
Best practice
The impersonal nature of relationships in a bureaucratic organization is one of its main strengths, enabling efficient functioning independent of personal relationships.
Market and non-market organizations
Segmentation of organizations

The set of organizations is too vast and heterogeneous to be analyzed effectively as a whole. It is therefore necessary to divide it into subsets that are easier to observe.

Type of organization Characteristics
Market organizations Produce goods or services intended for the market. Example: companies (the main focus of this course)
Non-market organizations Do not pursue a primary commercial objective. Include: public administrations, non-profit associations, political parties, trade unions, NGOs
Definition
Company
Organisation that uses the factors capital and labour to produce goods and/or services sold on a market, with the aim of maximising its profit.

Each of these two subsets can be refined according to additional criteria such as legal status, size, activity or performance.

Tip
Although market and non-market organisations have distinct characteristics, they face management problems of the same nature. Only the intensity of the problems and the responses provided change depending on their specificities.
Management fundamentals: individuals and objectives

All organisations, whether market or non-market, public or private, small or large, are purposeful and hierarchical human collectives.

It is precisely around the question of motivating individuals within these groups — organised to achieve objectives — that the major issues of management are built. The raw material of managerial concerns is indeed the same: individuals and groups of individuals within organisations.

Your turn to reflect
What fundamental differences do you observe between managing a small team in a startup and running a department within a large administration? What do they have in common in terms of management?
Management contexts and contingencies
Contingent management: adapting to the context

Although managerial issues remain similar, the responses to be provided largely depend on the context in which they arise. Management is a contingent exercise, meaning that managers' actions are influenced by the system of constraints and the resources available.

Among the essential contingency variables are:

  • The distribution of power
  • The influence of stakeholders
  • The purpose of the organization
  • The size and legal status
  • The cultural or ideological elements

These factors play a decisive role in guiding management decisions and behaviors.

Typical organization profiles

Small and very small enterprises

They rely mainly on family capital and finance their growth through debt. The manager plays a central role: they set the objectives and impose their management style. Management relationships there are direct and little formalized.

Large corporate enterprises

They finance their growth through financial markets. They are distinguished by formalized governance structures, where shareholders set the objectives and control the appointed managers. The latter delegate day-to-day management to the line hierarchy by establishing internal principles based on formalized rules and procedures.

Organizations with a social purpose

Like cooperatives, mutual societies or certain associations, they mainly pursue social utility and promote values such as solidarity. They share some characteristics with non-profit organizations (trade unions, NGOs).

Public sector organizations

They fall into two distinct categories:

  • Public enterprises: they resemble large corporations, although the State plays a central role as shareholder
  • Non-market public organizations: such as central government departments or local authorities, they are distinguished by a strong ideological footprint. Their objectives are often shaped by political decisions, and their operations focus more on means than on results
Gradual convergence of organizational models

Recent developments show a certain convergence between initially different situations. For example:

Traditional cooperatives (solidarity) Gradual conversion Behavior similar to the private sector

Some cooperatives and SCOPs (Sociétés coopératives ouvrières de production, worker production cooperatives) continue to uphold solidarity values. However, many mutual insurers and banks adopt behaviors similar to those of private companies. Their growth often requires greater capital fluidity: they set up «listed vehicles» that allow part of the capital to be converted into freely transferable shares, in order to raise resources on financial markets (for example: Crédit Agricole).

Similarly, public sector organizations tend to move closer to private sector management methods. This is particularly visible in companies facing competition, where the State has become a minority shareholder. Even in sectors where the State remains the majority shareholder (postal services, energy), there is a gradual opening to competition, accompanied by modernization of management practices.

This dynamic also affects the public sector. The LOLF introduced a approach focused on performance in public management. This reform aims to replace the culture of resources — long predominant — with a results-based culture, inspired by the private sector.

THE ESSENTIALS

Despite their contextual differences, all organizations face management problems of the same nature. Structures and practices evolve, but the fundamental challenges — motivating individuals toward common goals — remain at the heart of organizational management.

Stakeholders and social responsibility
Organizations as complex systems

Organizations form a heterogeneous whole and can be viewed as complex human collectives, made up of individuals and groups with sometimes divergent interests, including with regard to the very objectives of the organization.

It would be reductive to analyze an organization as a homogeneous block in which all individuals share identical objectives aligned with those of the organization.

By adopting a systemic view, an organization can be described as a set of distinct components interacting with various entities in its environment. Some of these entities lie within the organization's boundaries, while others are located outside. Each pursues specific objectives that may sometimes conflict, more or less openly.

This situation gives rise to the "political" dimension of organizations. Studying power in an organization consists of identifying the actors — individuals or groups — capable of influencing or modifying the behavior of others. To do so, these actors use various means: persuasion, incentives, or coercion.

Definition and origins of the stakeholder concept
Definition
Stakeholders
All the actors, internal or external to the organization, who determine its functioning while depending, at least partially, on it to achieve their own objectives. Actors or organizations that may be directly or indirectly affected by the company's activity.

The term stakeholders comes from the translation of the English word stakeholders (literally "holders of stakes"), in contrast to shareholders (holders of shares). This notion became widely disseminated, notably following reflections on corporate governance and the growing role of stakeholders, in reaction to the financial scandals of the early 2000s (Enron, WorldCom, Parmalat, Vivendi, Ahold, etc.). The concept is attributed to Freeman (1984).

Stakeholder categories in a business

In a commercial company, stakeholders fall into several categories:

  • Resource providers: shareholders, creditors, employees, executives
  • Internal components: subsidiaries, departments, etc.
  • Actors in the economic, political, social and technological environment: suppliers, customers, competitors, distributors, local authorities where the company is located, the State (tax revenues, subsidies), trade unions, consumer movements, etc.

These actors interact with the organization, influence it and are themselves affected by its decisions, illustrating the complexity of relationships in an organizational environment.

Vigilance
The expectations of these different stakeholders are often contradictory. They result in tensions between short and long term, between economic and social logics, between growth and profitability, autonomy and control…
Governance and prioritization of stakeholders

It is essential to identify stakeholders' interests as well as the power they hold, which can influence the organization's decisions. Depending on its configuration, size, legal status and purpose, the organization will not give the same level of importance to the objectives and aspirations of its stakeholders.

The role of stakeholders, the consideration of their expectations, the conflicts of interest that may arise from them, as well as their influence on strategic directions and the functioning of organizations, are at the heart of governance issues.

Corporate social responsibility: definition and issues
Definition
Corporate social responsibility (CSR)
Capacity of the company to take into account the interests of its various stakeholders in its management.

This raises the question of how companies manage these different expectations, which is addressed in the debate around corporate social responsibility (CSR).

"The minimalist approach holds that "the social responsibility of the company is to increase its profits" (Friedman, 1970). Proponents of this approach adhere to neoclassical theory, which holds that maximizing the wealth of the company will lead to the general well-being. At the opposite end, stakeholder theory (Freeman, 1984) suggests that the company's responsibilities are much broader. It is no longer a matter of maximizing shareholder wealth but of promoting a balance between the stakeholders identified by the company."

— Frédérique Déjean and Madina Rival, « Les stratégies hors marché, nouveaux enjeux pour l'entreprise », Communication aux États Généraux du Management, 2012

Whether it is an ethical choice or a financial interest, the company should also, in the long term, take into account the well-being of its employees, which would qualify it as a socially responsible company. Conversely, some companies such as Gap or Nike have, in the past, been accused of resorting to child labor.

More broadly, we speak of corporate social responsibility (CSR) when it comes to considering the expectations of other stakeholders. This may include, for example, respect for suppliers (a subject on which Carrefour is regularly challenged) or even dialogue with consumer associations or local residents.

A company that pays attention to all of its stakeholders is sometimes described as a good corporate citizen.

Contemporary issues in CSR

Two key issues deserve to be highlighted:

1
Internationalization and outsourcing
The internationalization and outsourcing of companies make it harder for headquarters to control those who carry out the work. These practices, in particular the use of foreign subcontractors, have allowed companies such as Gap and Nike to justify failures related to child labor.
2
Respect for the environment
Respect for the environment, often grouped under the concepts of sustainable development or sustainable development (first appearing in 1987 in the Brundtland Report), implies that companies produce or sell while preserving natural resources so as not to compromise the needs of future generations.

According to the theories presented, Friedman's approach (1970) holds that the social responsibility of a company is to increase its profits, based on neoclassical theory. Conversely, Freeman (1984) proposes that the company's responsibilities extend well beyond that: it is about fostering a balance between all identified stakeholders, and not merely maximizing shareholder wealth.

To remember

  • Management applies to all organizations, whether commercial or not, because it addresses a universal challenge: motivating individuals toward collective goals.
  • Organizations are distinguished from other human groups by a specific purpose, qualified personnel, formalized communication systems, rules and procedures, and impersonal relationships.
  • Management is contingent: the actions of managers vary according to the constraints and resources of the context (distribution of power, stakeholders, purpose, size, cultural elements).
  • The different types of organizations (small businesses, large companies, social-purpose organizations, the public sector) are experiencing a gradual convergence toward hybrid management practices, combining market and non-market logics.
  • Stakeholders are all internal or external actors who influence the organization and depend on it. Their often conflicting expectations create a political dimension within the organization.
  • Corporate social responsibility (CSR) consists of taking into account the interests of all stakeholders, not just shareholders. It encompasses employee well-being, respect for suppliers, dialogue with consumers, and environmental protection.
  • The major challenges of contemporary CSR are internationalization/outsourcing (control of subcontractors) and sustainable development (preservation of natural resources for future generations).
Recommended resources
Reinventing Organizations
Frederic Laloux — Explores new paradigms for structuring and leading organizations, highlighting innovative and inspiring models.
Compassionate Management
Philippe Rodet and Yves Desjacques — Highlights the importance of compassion in managerial practices to improve both employee well-being and team performance.
Dream Team
Ludovic Girodon — Offers practical advice on building and managing a high-performing team, enriched with testimonials from experienced managers.

Create your free account

No credit card required, in thirty seconds.
Continue with Google
or
Sign up with an e-mail
Already registered? Log in
By continuing, you agree to the terms of use and the privacy policy. Your data is hosted in the European Union.

Full access DATAGOZ

19 €/ month — or 190 € / year
  • All published courses and career paths
  • Exercises and quizzes with automatic grading
  • Practice, exam and certificate of completion
  • No commitment, cancel online
See the plans
This lesson is part of the course

Master the Fundamentals of Management

short_training24 chapters · 74 lessons

Advance your career with the fundamentals of Project Management!

  • The training platformsubscribers
  • The management course fieldyou are here
  • Management: definition and developmentssubscribers
  • Running an organizationsubscribers
  • Every manager's definition of management: the case of Guccisubscribers
  • Power and leadershipsubscribers
  • The value of theoretical approaches and how to approach themsubscribers
  • Concise and chronological overview of theoretical schools of thoughtsubscribers
  • The contributions of economistssubscribers
  • The contributions of sociologistssubscribers
  • The classical school: the dominance of rational thinkingsubscribers
  • The human relations school: taking human behavior into accountsubscribers
  • The socio-technical school: joint optimization of the social and the technicalsubscribers
  • The behavioral school: decision-making processes in a complex systemsubscribers
  • The contingency school: the weight of external determinants on the organizationsubscribers
  • Current theoretical schools of thoughtsubscribers
  • Standard characteristics of strategic decision-makingsubscribers
  • Representations of rationality and decision modelssubscribers
  • The contemporary context of planningsubscribers
  • How planning was implemented at Shellsubscribers
  • The limits of strategic planningsubscribers
  • Analysis of the company: its identity and diversitysubscribers
  • Analysis of the environment and the firm's competitive positionsubscribers
  • Diagnosis of resources and their implementationsubscribers
  • Summary of the diagnosis and formulation of possible courses of actionsubscribers
  • Overall strategiessubscribers
  • Business-level strategies for SBUssubscribers
  • Functional strategiessubscribers
  • Strategy and general organisation of the companysubscribers
  • The question of resource allocationsubscribers
  • Strategic and structural changesubscribers
  • Knowledge in the service of marketing strategysubscribers
  • Reflection in the service of marketing strategysubscribers
  • Action in the service of marketing strategysubscribers
  • Introduction: recent developmentssubscribers
  • Production managementsubscribers
  • Just-in-time productionsubscribers
  • Towards industrial and logistics managementsubscribers
  • The financial function and the financialisation of the economysubscribers
  • The actors of the financialisation of the economysubscribers
  • The implications of the financialisation of the economysubscribers
  • Innovation in the companysubscribers
  • The complexity of innovation processessubscribers
  • The challenges of innovationsubscribers
  • Managing innovationsubscribers
  • The HR function in the company: its contribution and its placesubscribers
  • Personnel administrationsubscribers
  • Employment policiessubscribers
  • Acquisition, evaluation and compensation of human resourcessubscribers
  • Human resources developmentsubscribers
  • Social climate and industrial relationssubscribers
  • Skills management addresses multiple and varied challengessubscribers
  • The concept of competencesubscribers
  • Management of skills practicessubscribers
  • Skills management toolssubscribers
  • Skills management: key success factors and limitationssubscribers
  • The individual in the organisationsubscribers
  • Groups in the organisationsubscribers
  • Conflicts: definitions and componentssubscribers
  • Theoretical modelssubscribers
  • Conflict management: diagnosis and analysissubscribers
  • Intervention strategies: conflict resolution methodssubscribers
  • Origins and theoretical frameworksubscribers
  • Some interactions/contributions in the social sciencessubscribers
  • The place of internal communicationsubscribers
  • Internal communication mediasubscribers
  • Internal communication auditsubscribers
  • The place of marketing communicationsubscribers
  • Media, channels and communication mixsubscribers
  • From objectives to a marketing communication auditsubscribers
  • The place of financial communicationsubscribers
  • Financial communication mediasubscribers
  • Criteria for assessing the effectiveness of financial communicationsubscribers
  • Course conclusionsubscribers
Next lesson

Management: definition and developments

View the programme Create an account to continue